Key Takeaways
- Payers treat ongoing psychotherapy as medically necessary when the record shows a diagnosed condition, an individualized treatment plan, and improvement or a reasonable expectation of improvement.
- Wellpoint Federal’s Medicare psychiatry LCD treats services as no longer medically necessary when the patient stays stable without them or further improvement is not expected, and it separately covers treatment designed to prevent relapse or hospitalization.
- Insufficient documentation accounted for 78.3% of improper Medicare Part B payments for psychiatry services in the 2024 reporting period, according to CMS.
- Health plans subject to federal parity law must provide their mental health medical necessity criteria to contracting providers on request.
- Members of most private health plans have 180 days to file an internal appeal and four months after a final internal denial to request external review.
Payers decide medical necessity for psychotherapy by asking whether the record supports continuing care, so a correctly coded claim can still deny when the documentation stops showing why treatment should go on. Notes that show progress against a treatment plan answer that question, and an appeal written to the payer’s criteria addresses denials that come anyway.
What Is Medical Necessity for Psychotherapy?
Medical necessity for psychotherapy means the treatment addresses a diagnosed mental health condition under an individualized treatment plan, and the patient is improving or can reasonably be expected to improve. In Medicare, each Medicare Administrative Contractor publishes local coverage determinations (LCDs). The Psychiatry and Psychology Services LCD (L33632) from Wellpoint Federal (formerly National Government Services) states that its medical necessity parameters may also apply to services billed to Part B by individual providers, and it ties continued coverage to documented improvement under the treatment plan.
The LCD says services are no longer medically necessary when stability can be maintained without further treatment or with less intensive treatment, or when there is no reasonable expectation of further improvement. It separately covers treatment designed to reduce or control psychiatric symptoms to prevent relapse or hospitalization. For a stable patient, the record should explain what continued therapy is preventing. Commercial plans apply separate criteria that look for the same core evidence: a current diagnosis, symptoms or functional impairment, measurable goals, and progress.
What Should Psychotherapy Documentation Show to Support Continued Treatment?
Documentation supports continued psychotherapy when each note connects the session to the treatment plan and shows where the patient stands against its goals. Wellpoint Federal’s LCD L33632 lists an individualized treatment plan among its general coverage requirements, stating the type, amount, frequency, and duration of services, along with the diagnoses and anticipated goals. Session notes should add:
- A diagnosis the note supports, with symptoms and functional limits described in terms that match it
- The plan goal the session addressed, so a reviewer can follow treatment from note to note
- Measurable progress, such as PHQ-9 or GAD-7 scores, work or school attendance, or the frequency of panic attacks
- Plan updates when progress changes, with a revised approach or goals when the patient plateaus
- The reason treatment continues when goals are partly met, including the risk of relapse or decline if therapy stops
- Session start and stop times, which also set the code under the time thresholds for CPT 90832, 90834, and 90837
Notes that repeat the same language from session to session give a reviewer no evidence of change, so cloned or template-heavy notes are a common reason ongoing therapy fails review.
Why Do Payers Deny Ongoing Psychotherapy as Not Medically Necessary?
Payers deny ongoing psychotherapy as not medically necessary when the record does not show why treatment should continue. Medical necessity is one of the most common denial categories across specialties. In psychotherapy, these denials typically carry claim adjustment reason code (CARC) 50, which Noridian’s reason code guidance describes as non-covered services because they are not deemed a medical necessity by the payer. Common patterns behind them include:
- A treatment plan written at intake and never updated
- Goals with no measurable target, such as “improve mood”
- Months of notes with no change in symptoms and no explanation of why therapy continues
- A diagnosis that does not match the severity or impairment described in the notes
Medicare’s improper payment data shows how often documentation falls short in review. For psychiatry services billed under Medicare Part B, CMS reports a 16.1% improper payment rate in the 2024 reporting period, with insufficient documentation behind 78.3% of improper payments and missing documentation behind another 17%. Those figures cover all documentation errors found in review, not only medical necessity denials.
Denials can come before payment, during a payer’s concurrent review of a behavioral health authorization, or after payment through a retrospective audit.
How Do Commercial Payers Decide Whether Therapy Is Medically Necessary?
Commercial payers decide medical necessity using their own clinical criteria, which may be proprietary guidelines or criteria from a behavioral health administrator that manages the plan’s mental health benefits. Federal parity law limits how those criteria are applied. Under 29 CFR 2590.712(d)(1), a plan must make its medical necessity criteria for mental health and substance use disorder benefits available to any current or potential participant, beneficiary, or contracting provider on request.
The Department of Labor named medical necessity standards and review processes as one of three parity enforcement priorities in Field Assistance Bulletin 2026-03, issued Sept. 8, 2026. The bulletin says the agency will focus on prior authorization, concurrent review, and retrospective review, and that plans may use proprietary guidelines as long as the standards are comparable to, and applied no more stringently than, those for medical and surgical benefits. When a plan carves out behavioral health to a separate administrator, that administrator issues the denial and handles the appeal.
How Do You Appeal a Medical Necessity Denial for Psychotherapy?
Appeal a medical necessity denial by showing, criterion by criterion, that the record meets the standard the payer used. The steps apply to commercial plans and Medicare, with differences in deadlines and levels:
- Start with the denial notice. Identify the criteria or policy cited, the dates of service affected, and the deadline to appeal.
- Request the payer’s criteria. For commercial plans, ask for the medical necessity criteria the reviewer applied. For Medicare, check the LCD that applies in your jurisdiction.
- Ask for a peer-to-peer review when the payer offers one. A conversation between the treating clinician and the payer’s reviewer can resolve a denial before a written appeal.
- Write the appeal to the criteria. Address each criterion the payer cited and point to the note, plan update, or measure result that satisfies it.
- Attach the supporting records. Include the current treatment plan, recent progress notes, and standardized measure results, limited to what the criteria require.
- Escalate when the first appeal fails. Private plan members can request external review of denials involving medical judgment within four months of the final internal denial, and Medicare allows 180 days from the redetermination decision to request reconsideration.
Track every appeal by date filed and response due, because a late appeal can be dismissed.
What Are the Deadlines for Appealing a Psychotherapy Denial?
Appeal deadlines depend on the payer. Under the Affordable Care Act appeal rules, which apply to most private health plans, a member has 180 days to file an internal appeal, according to HealthCare.gov, and four months after the final internal denial to request external review. Original Medicare allows 120 days from the initial determination to request a redetermination, followed by reconsideration and an administrative law judge hearing.
The private plan deadlines are member appeal rights, which a provider can exercise on the patient’s behalf with the patient’s authorization. In-network providers may also have a separate provider dispute or reconsideration process under their payer contract, with deadlines that can differ from the member rules.
| Appeal step | Deadline to file | Decision or threshold |
| Private plan: member internal appeal | Within 180 days of receiving the denial notice | Within 60 days for a service already received |
| Private plan: external review | Within four months of receiving the final internal denial | Within 45 days for a standard review; the insurer must accept the result |
| Medicare: redetermination | Within 120 days of the initial determination | Completed within 60 days of receipt by the Medicare Administrative Contractor |
| Medicare: reconsideration | Within 180 days of the redetermination decision | Filed with a Qualified Independent Contractor; completed within 60 days of receipt |
| Medicare: administrative law judge | Within 60 days of receiving the reconsideration | At least $200 in controversy |
How PGM Supports Behavioral Health Denials and Appeals
PGM has provided independent medical billing and revenue cycle management since 1981, with dedicated support for mental and behavioral health practices. Services include eligibility and benefits verification, prior authorization support, coding review, claims submission, denial management and appeals, and payment posting and reporting across commercial, Medicare, and Medicaid payers.
If medical necessity denials are slowing payment for ongoing therapy, talk to PGM’s behavioral health billing team. For what to expect from a specialized partner, see how to choose a behavioral health billing company.
* * *
Frequently Asked Questions About Medical Necessity for Psychotherapy
Does Medicare limit the number of psychotherapy sessions it covers?
No. Wellpoint Federal’s Psychiatry and Psychology Services LCD (L33632) states that there are no specific limits on the length of time psychotherapy may be covered, although prolonged treatment may be subject to medical necessity review and the provider must document the need for it. Other Medicare contractors publish their own LCDs, so check the one for your jurisdiction. Medicare Advantage plans set separate review and authorization rules.
Can a practice bill the patient when therapy is denied as not medically necessary?
For Original Medicare, only if the practice gave the patient a valid Advance Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage before the service. According to Noridian’s ABN guidance, a patient who did not receive a valid ABN cannot be billed, and practices may not issue ABNs on a routine basis. Claims with a valid ABN carry the GA modifier. For commercial plans, the network contract determines whether a member can be billed for a medical necessity denial.
Do payers need psychotherapy notes to review medical necessity?
No. HIPAA defines psychotherapy notes as a clinician’s notes on the contents of a counseling session that are kept separate from the medical record, and disclosing them generally requires the patient’s authorization. The definition excludes medication prescription and monitoring, session start and stop times, treatment modalities and frequencies, test results, and summaries of the diagnosis, functional status, treatment plan, symptoms, prognosis, and progress, as Holland & Hart’s HIPAA summary explains. Those excluded items are the evidence payers review, so they belong in the medical record.